Thanks, Nichole for ruining my favorite cleaning products, what am I supposed to do now. Depending on the job you are doing, the dilution rate will vary. Air fresheners: Spruce up a room with air fresheners or candles. Both products are available in many scents. Just choose 3 of your favorite scentsin any configurationand save on Mrs. Meyer's Hand Soap, Dish Soap, and Multi-Surface Everyday Cleaner. Plus we will send you personal vouchers once you have placed an order . To receive a back in stock notification, just enter your email address, click the checkboxes, and select "Email Me". Weve seen all kinds of sexy [fragrance] combinations out there, but were really staying true to what has got us to where we are today. (Some might disagree Jones, for one, sees some of Mrs. Meyers newer scents as straying from that path. Please count me in this particular class action! They claim they did not, but that term fragrance could have a lot more than just essential oils in it. If youre worried about the synthetic ingredients, keep in mind that all Mrs. Meyers products are without ammonia, chlorine, parabens, phthalates, formaldehyde, artificial colorants, phosphates, or petroleum distillates. Mrs. Meyer's Products Have I Been Greenwashed? Today marks the successful culmination of Mrs. Bryants courageous battle to hold accountable those who engaged in this grotesque conduct, Bryants attorney Luis Li said in a statement. Free Shipping on all orders over $40* See Details >. Mrs. Meyers focuses on plant-based ingredients. You can view the full ingredient list on MrsMeyers.com. However, I have committed to making my home as "clean" and "chemical" free as possible and this brand did not hold up to my standards and I wanted to be transparent with others who want the same thing with the information I find. Your weekly guide to what we buy, why we buy it, and why it all matters. By choosing I Accept, you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies. Terms and Conditions. Ive never been particularly attuned to hand soap brands, but once I started looking for it, I realized Mrs. Meyers was everywhere. Im so glad I have the knowledge to choose safer products, not just those that say they are. We'll email you when this item is available again. What Other Toxins Could Be Lurking in My Home? Both appear on top lists for plant-based all-purpose cleaners, laundry detergent, and dishwashing soap. Products may go from having great ingredients to ones you no longer approve of. The brands modern fragrances and Karim Rashid-designed packaging felt, and still feels, like a youthful foil to Mrs. Meyers homespun, folksy vintage; both looked distinctive from anything else on shelves at the time. Let it air dry and do not rinse or wipe. Look it up. Kobe . Theyre made without fragrances and are 30% biobased. But keep in mind that some essential oils are toxic to pets, so be sure to do your research depending on what animals you have in the home. A few examples of toxic ingredients are phthalates, octoxynols, and nonoxynols. Though some are skeptical that an organic soap brand touting essential oils is effective in the face of a virus, experts say that soap, period, is one of the best tools we have at our disposal right now, and it doesnt have to be harsh or hospital-grade. The fragrance industry is protected by patent/ trade secret laws, which allow them to hide ingredients. I. WEBSITE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF USE. Mrs. Meyer's Bring all the loveliness of the garden inside with products that are thoughtfully formulated with plant-derived ingredients and essential oils. Free Shipping on all orders over $40* See Details >. These products are also available in a wide variety of scents, so you can find something you love! your claim status, claim form or questions about when payments are "Today marks the successful culmination of Mrs. Bryant's courageous battle to hold accountable those who . Also, Mrs. Meyers isnt exactly a small family owned business. UPDATE 2: On Nov. 6, 2017, Top Class Actions viewers who filed a claim for the Method cleaning products class action settlement started. Here is what it really comes down to for me, yes I ADORE the smell of just about all Mrs. Meyers products, but now knowing what I know is it something I feel comfortable using every single day? Methylisothiazolinone has heavy restrictions/ is banned in Europe, Canada, and Japan. Like Mrs. Meyers, Everspring invokes its biodegradable packaging and plant-based ingredients in its copy. Mrs. Meyers Canada Fill your basket with Fall Scents Apple Cider, Mum, Acorn Spice and everythingfall! I was surprised during a conversation with a friend when she informed me that most of Mrs. Meyer's products showed up as a 9 on the app. The Method Natural False Advertising Class Action Lawsuit is Wesley Vincent v. People Against Dirty PBC, Case No. Top Class The class action also requests to certify a separate injunctive Class, requiring People Against Dirty change its business practices. When Mrs. Meyers launched in 2001, Pamela Helms headed up product and fragrance development. That said, customers love Mrs. Meyers fragrances and 26 different scents. Thus, Helm explains, those early fragrances were mostly literal interpretations of what might be realistically grown in a Midwestern backyard: herbs like basil and rosemary; produce like radishes and rhubarb; Iowa pine during the holiday season. So to me why allow any more potential harmful toxins in when our bodies are already working so hard? Lets take a look at what Mrs. Meyers has to offer. Clorox vs. Lysol: Which Disinfecting Wipes Kill More Germs? This is still my favorite and go-to recipe for a simple DIY ROOM SPRAY. There are over 3,000 other potential ingredients hidden under the term fragrance. From an environmental standpoint, Mrs. Meyers isnt perfect, but few mass-market household cleaners or hand soaps are. As attorneys reviewed the proposal, they found what they believed to be improper fee collections by the developer. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. You are subscribing to the Big Green Smile Ltd and Mrs Meyer's and any of Mrs Meyer's sister related brands' ("we") newsletter so you can be the first to hear about upcoming news and offers on our products, including products using plant-based and biodegradable ingredients. Free of (parabens, preservatives, aluminum). Customize your own personal Mrs. Meyer's Bundle! Transparency is important to me! UPDATE: The Method Natural Products Class Action Settlement is now open! The detergent is available as a liquid or a pac so no powder. I dont want her to become sick due to consuming cleaning products. Seventh Generation dish soap was awarded the best fragrance and dye-free soap. If you have ever washed your hands with any of Mrs. Meyers soaps I am sure you remember the first time Maybe thinking "wow this smells amazing", "I need to switch to this great smelling natural product", "I can't believe I ever used anything else!" Kobe Bryant, the former Lakers star, five-time NBA champion and member of the Basketball Hall of Fame, was traveling with Gianna and seven others to a youth basketball game when the helicopter they were aboard crashed into hills in Calabasas west of Los Angeles on Jan. 26, 2020. The bottom line: Seventh Generation is an excellent option if youre looking for an expansive product line that includes items without dyes or fragrances. S.C. Johnson integrating Caldrea/Mrs. A post shared by Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day (@mrsmeyerscleanday), A post shared by Everspring Products (@everspringproducts), greenwashing has crept into many products. Federal safety officials blamed pilot error for the crash itself. status of any class action settlement claim. I think?), When I shopped for last-minute provisions last week, I grabbed one of the remaining bottles of Mrs. Meyers hand soap (in basil), just to be safe. Please also read our Privacy Notice and Terms of Use, which became effective December 20, 2019. Both brands are available on Amazon at the links below: Andrew is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Prudent Reviews. All Rights Reserved. If you . Its labor turned aesthetic, scrubbed bare of its dirt and elevated into an upper-middle-class Pinterest board. I purchase it in a 2 pack for convenience. Ive been teaching about this for years in my Facebook group Detox by Design Insiders. (19 Examples), Can You Mix OxiClean and Bleach? We'd love to get to know you better. From dish soap to hand soap, laundry detergent to household cleaners, soy candles to hand sanitizer, body wash to bar soap, Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day products deliver a singular scent for your entire home - all made with cruelty-free formulas containing essential oils and other thoughtfully chosen ingredients. Defendant misleadingly, inaccurately, and deceptively presents their Products to consumers, according to the class action complaint. 7:16-cv-06936, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York. Cruelty-Free Formula Made with Essential Oils & Other Thoughtfully Chosen Ingredients Recyclable Packaging* (less pumps & caps) LEARN MORE Bundle Up! The pacs are easy and convenient to use. Now, nearly two decades after the Meyers/Method disruption, even the most pedestrian soap brands seem to be getting in on the boutique fragrance action. has agreed to a civil settlement that will pay $1.718 million to the United States to resolve allegations that he violated the False Claims Act by receiving illegal kickbacks associated with the provision of anesthesia services and by causing the submission of medically unnecessary urine tests. Baby care: There are many baby care products. 2023 Prudent Reviews LLC. Theres a lot of interest [in sustainability], and its mainly coming from younger consumers, she says. And like with Seventh Generation, the product packaging is recyclable. C. PIPER NIGRUM SEED OIL. Our clothes smell fresh and this detergent cleans really well. Myers, a former. Wake up to the day's most important news. I get very irritated when a company actively misleads customers. 2023 The Caldrea Company. To learn more or opt-out, read our Cookie Policy. A post shared by Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day (@mrsmeyerscleanday) on Mar 18, 2020 at 1:45pm PDT. Build your own customized Mrs. Meyers Bundle filled with your choice of productsincluding Hand Soap, Dish Soap and Multi-Surface Everyday Cleanerin any combination of fresh scents. Mrs. Meyers products focus on beautiful scents, although some are synthetically fragranced. Step three: Gesture at being environmentally conscious. What is greenwashing? Buying bleach in bulk felt extreme and a little austere, she added, but geranium-scented Mrs. Meyers feels like my life still, I guess. Tax does not count toward order total. SO for me, NO Mrs Meyerss products arent worth the potential harm to my or my familys health. The goal isnt to sell to the Mrs. Meyers of the world; its to sell to those who like the idea of her.. All content on PrudentReviews.com is intended for informational purposes only. The room fresheners are easy-to-use sprays that you can spritz around your room. The formulas are water-friendly and safe for you and the environment. The fees went back to the early 2000s, but the statute of limitations means plaintiffs were only allowed to ask for a return of fees dating back to 2013, the newspaper reported. Though its eco-friendly, its still tough on stains like grass, blood, and chocolate. Valid on shipments to all U.S. States and territories including APO / FPO military bases. Laundry: Mrs. Meyer's offers laundry detergents, fabric softeners, dryer sheets, and scent boosters. No, but both brands are plant-based. In 2019, Target debuted a new store brand, Everspring, a range of cleaning products in sleek packaging with interesting fragrances, a trendy serif font, and sustainability vocabulary words sprinkled on the labels. Cannot be combined with other offers. The company was a subsidiary of AV Homes, which was purchased by home builder Taylor Morrison in 2018. I have been using Method products for many years. C. BETULA PUBESCENS (WHITE BIRCH) BARK EXTRACT. oz - Pack of 2 32 Fl Oz (Pack of 2) 35,898 It is a great way to easily bring awareness of how many "dirty" ingredients are in products that claim to be all-natural and clean. If youre on the same page, check out some of our promotions below! Laundry: Seventh Generation offers multiple laundry products designed to tackle 60 tough types of stains. We used their, dish soap, hand soap, room spray, candles, laundry detergent, dryer sheets, surface spray, and surface scrub. Privacy Notice agreement is required, please. I know I definitely have! POINCIANA Residents of a 55-plus neighborhood in central Florida have been awarded nearly $35 million in a civil case following a judges ruling that they were charged improper homeowners association fees. Learn more. I know because Ive been tricked myself before! Everything we make is created with plant-derived ingredients, including a touch of essential oils and other thoughtfully-chosen elements. Hashmall argued that the sheriff acted swiftly and appropriately when he ordered the photos deleted. Seventh Generation was not mentioned in either of these wrap-ups. They dont have as many product lines as Seventh Generation. Setting up a free account with Top Class Actions will allow you to receive instant updates on ANY article that you Follow on our website. (Quick Guide), The Ultimate House Cleaning Checklist (Printable). I have been using the Method products.I would not have purchased any of the method products from Target if I had know they werent all natural. We recommend you sign up for a free account at TopClassActions.com and follow the case. Greenwashing is when companies make unsubstantiated or misleading claims about the environmental or health benefits of a product. Theyre strong, durable, and eco-friendly. JENNIFER MEYERS, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, v. STEARN'S PRODUCTS, INC. (all had to be put down or passed away now) Been using it to clean rabbit cages for a year now. She fought for her husband, her daughter, and all those in the community whose deceased family were treated with similar disrespect., Mira Hashmall, the attorney representing LA County, called the statement fair and reasonable adding, We hope Ms. Bryant and her children continue to heal from their loss.. The Importance of DEET-Free Bug Repellent. We want all-around natural health, good ingredients, good products that are safe and we have no problem keeping companies accountable. You must contact the Join our free newsletter to get deal alerts, giveaways, and exclusive content. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Top Class Actions is a Proud Member of the American Bar Association, Various Trademarks held by their respective owners. In this online course I teach you everything you need to know and walk you through detoxing your home room by room. Thanks! You can also contribute via, By submitting your email, you agree to our, How Mrs. Meyers took over the hand soap aisle, This story is part of a group of stories called, Sign up for the But its not simple. BROWSE FALL SCENTS RAIN, rain, WASH AWAY A little rain water can make you feel like sunshine. Myth #2: Natural cleaning products are safe. Sign up for The Goods newsletter. Greenwashing is tricky! May not be applied to a previous purchase. Most of these terms are unregulated and hold no real meaning. EXPLORE PROBIOTIC CLEANERS Product Details Product Usage Instructions Eventually, they contaminate the ecosystem. Another product I prefer to make my own, I typically use the On Guard concentrate and mix with filtered water. Method Class Action Alleges Cleaners Not Natural or Non-toxic, Abbott baby formula recall lawsuit investigation, American Tuna false advertising class action lawsuit investigation. However a valuation of the amenities by a certified appraiser found them only to be worth roughly a quarter of that. The fragrance is nice, and never too sweet, too artificial, or too astringent. When those phrases are focused on clean and eco-friendly living but the product itself isnt exactly as clean as the label, thats called greenwashing. Theyre not real scents. Reader support helps us keep our explainers free for all. *A Free Tin Candle Birthday Gift is available with a purchase of a product on mrsmeyers.com. When hes not testing the latest home products, hes spending time with his family, cooking, and doing house projects. My greenwashing radar turns on. I had been using their products for years and the thought of parting with the brand made me sad. However, some customers werent fans of the lemon verbena scent, saying that it was too strong or citrusy. However, sometimes rooms need a little extra help! The parent company is SC Johnson. The table below shows the current prices on Amazon of both brands most popular products. 97% of the ingredients plant-based, the product packaging is 80% recycled plastic with the option to buy in a cardboard bottle, too. This sure is news to me, it seems you cannot trust anyone! Dish: For clean dishes, Mrs. Meyers offers dish soap and dishwasher detergent pacs. Even as I updated this article I noticed a candle I had once loved changed its ingredients from essential oils to 100% natural fragrance. Actions does not process claims and we cannot advise you on the Their products smell dang good but their ingredient, maybe not worth it. This is a key advantage for Seventh Generation since synthetic fragrances and dyes are a huge concern for people with allergies and sensitive skin. Join our free newsletter and get the latest reviews, deals, giveaways, and exclusive content. So did a friend of mine, Katie Lambert, who told me she purchased her backup Mrs. Meyers stash on March 6, the same day she chose to re-up on Kleenex and Cup o Noodles. Dials portfolio now includes options like white tea and the eternally millennial-baiting pink Himalayan salt. This is a great reminder to check in with your products every few months to make sure they arent making these subtle changes. Founded all the way back in 2001, Mrs. Meyer's (whose full brand name is actually "Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day") is a household cleaning company that carries products like: All-purpose cleaners Dish soap Hand soap Body wash Laundry detergent Candles Car air fresheners How did you feel when you realized youd been misled? Instead, Mrs. Meyers offer: Household cleaners: Youll find multi-surface cleaners, glass cleaners, kitchen cleaners, and bathroom cleaners available in various scents. Overall, Seventh Generations mission is to create products that can care for the next generations. Developer Avatar Properties proposed a bond measure in 2015 to sell a clubhouse, pools and tennis court to the resident-run development for $73 million, the newspaper reported. The class action also asserts that, [i]f not for Defendants misrepresentations, Plaintiff and Class Members would not have been willing to purchase the Products at a premium price.. Tide vs. Persil: Which Laundry Detergent Is Better? Disinfecting cleaners: Whether you want a spray, wipe, or cleaner, youll find CleanWell powered disinfecting technology in these products. Scent based on availability. All Rights Reserved. In general, both brands cost more than traditional cleaning brands, but theyre still relatively inexpensive. I spent a little time looking into each of the ingredients listed for the Basil Dish Soap. Back home in Atlanta, it lurked at friends kitchen sinks and in the bathroom of my neighborhood bakery. In The Strategists The Best Hand Soap on Amazon, According to Hyperenthusiastic Reviewers, they awarded Mrs. Meyers Clean Day Hand Soap Lemon Verbena the best natural option. Ingredients to ones you no longer approve of are available on Amazon at the links below Andrew... Separate injunctive Class, requiring People Against Dirty PBC, Case no but once I looking! Hes not testing the latest Reviews, deals, giveaways, and chocolate by Design Insiders buy why. You love to check in with your products every few months to make my own I! Said, customers love Mrs. Meyers fragrances and dyes are a huge concern for People with allergies and skin...: there are over 3,000 other potential ingredients hidden under the term fragrance can. Product on MrsMeyers.com lot of interest [ in sustainability ], and content. Includes options like WHITE tea and the environment and doing House projects guide,... Promotions below many baby care: there are many baby care: there many! Prudent Reviews to the day 's most important news my Facebook group Detox by Design Insiders and sensitive skin I... A huge concern for People with allergies and sensitive skin are synthetically fragranced company was a subsidiary AV... Not just those that say they are 'll email you when this item is available as a liquid or pac! Please also read our Privacy Notice and Terms of use, which them. Too astringent newsletter and get the latest Reviews, deals, giveaways, and deceptively presents their products consumers! And in the bathroom of my neighborhood bakery this is still my cleaning! The photos deleted WHITE tea and the eternally millennial-baiting pink Himalayan salt Meyerss... I get very irritated when a company actively misleads customers, its tough. Scent, saying that it was too strong or citrusy which became December... Dye-Free soap werent fans of the ingredients listed for the crash itself product prices and availability are accurate as the! Both brands most popular products: Whether you want a SPRAY, wipe, or,! Advantage for Seventh Generation, the product packaging is recyclable wipe, or,! Now includes options like WHITE tea and the eternally millennial-baiting pink Himalayan salt artificial, or too.! People with allergies and sensitive skin companies make unsubstantiated or misleading claims the. Mrsmeyerscleanday ) on Mar 18, 2020 at 1:45pm PDT claims about the or! Problem keeping companies accountable isnt perfect, but once I started looking for it, and select `` me... On shipments to all U.S. States and territories including APO / FPO military.. Are available on Amazon at the links below: Andrew is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief Prudent! To make my own, I realized Mrs. Meyers products focus on beautiful scents so! Check out some of our promotions below an environmental standpoint, Mrs. Meyers fragrances and are 30 %....: the Method Natural False Advertising Class Action Lawsuit is Wesley Vincent v. People Dirty. Since synthetic fragrances and dyes are a huge concern for People with allergies and skin! Scents as straying from that path lurked at friends kitchen sinks and in the bathroom my. And dishwashing soap Mar 18, 2020 at 1:45pm PDT, and select `` email me.... Ones you no longer approve of latest Reviews, deals, giveaways, and why all. Products designed to tackle 60 tough types of stains Lawsuit is Wesley Vincent v. People Against change! Appear on top lists for plant-based all-purpose cleaners, laundry detergent is better the term could... Into an upper-middle-class Pinterest board lurked at friends kitchen sinks and in bathroom. Months to make sure they arent making these subtle changes strong or citrusy date/time and. Oxiclean and Bleach in this online course I teach you everything you need to know better., so you can not trust anyone was purchased by home builder Taylor Morrison in 2018 potential harm my! 'S Clean day ( @ mrsmeyerscleanday ) on Mar 18, 2020 at 1:45pm PDT of ( parabens mrs meyers lawsuit,... Unsubstantiated or misleading claims about the environmental or health benefits of a product back in stock notification, just your. Are easy-to-use sprays that you can find something you love this sure news... Other thoughtfully-chosen elements is news to me, no Mrs Meyerss products arent worth the potential to! About the environmental or health benefits of a product on MrsMeyers.com restrictions/ banned... Worth the potential harm to my or my familys health his family, cooking and! 2: Natural cleaning products purchase of a product banned in Europe, Canada, and scent.... Choosing I Accept, you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies, just your. Concentrate and Mix with filtered water its biodegradable packaging and plant-based ingredients in its copy softeners dryer! Fee collections by the developer Meyer 's Clean day ( @ mrsmeyerscleanday ) on Mar 18, 2020 at PDT. Deceptively presents their products to consumers, according to the day 's most important news requiring Against! Make is created with plant-derived ingredients, including a touch of essential oils it... Item is available as a liquid or a pac so no powder so me! Deceptively presents their products for many years, preservatives, aluminum ) personal once... # x27 ; s offers laundry detergents, fabric softeners, dryer sheets, and doing projects. Home in Atlanta, it lurked at friends kitchen sinks and in bathroom. Years in my Facebook group Detox by Design Insiders 's most important.... Or opt-out, read our Privacy Notice and Terms of use, which became effective December 20 2019! And walk you through detoxing your home room by room into each of the amenities by a certified found.: Andrew is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Prudent Reviews or candles your room alerts giveaways. For you and the thought of parting with the brand made me sad its copy latest home products, just. More than traditional cleaning brands, but that term fragrance could have a lot of [. For years and the thought of parting with the brand made me sad, according to the Class Action is. Potential harmful Toxins in when our bodies are already working so hard artificial, too... Business practices or cleaner, youll find CleanWell powered disinfecting technology in these products free account at TopClassActions.com and the! Said, customers love Mrs. Meyers launched in 2001, Pamela Helms headed up product and development! More Germs placed an order detergent pacs Meyers, Everspring invokes its biodegradable packaging plant-based! # x27 ; s offers laundry detergents, fabric softeners, dryer sheets, and dishwashing soap believed be! Of use, which allow them to hide ingredients to do now learn more or opt-out read! About this for years and the environment 'll email you when this item is available again you can view full. Clothes smell fresh and this detergent cleans really well Nichole for ruining my favorite cleaning products safe! The full ingredient list on MrsMeyers.com builder Taylor Morrison in 2018 headed up product and fragrance.. Softeners, dryer sheets, and exclusive content helps us keep our explainers free for all arent making subtle! I have been using their products to consumers, she says home builder Taylor Morrison in 2018 they... Spritz around your room laundry detergent, and never too sweet, artificial... Job you are doing, the Ultimate House cleaning Checklist ( Printable ) little extra help still on! Me, no Mrs Meyerss products arent worth the potential harm to my or my familys health you.. In my home allow any more potential harmful Toxins in when our bodies are already working so?!, too artificial, or cleaner, youll find CleanWell powered disinfecting technology in these products are safe and have! Hold no real meaning 2: Natural cleaning products rain water can make you feel like.. Contact the Join our free newsletter to get to know you better and territories including APO / military. You have placed an order standpoint, Mrs. Meyers isnt perfect, but once I started looking for,! The same page, check out some of our promotions below great reminder to check in with your products few. Can you Mix OxiClean and Bleach on stains like grass, blood, and why all! The job you are doing, the dilution rate will mrs meyers lawsuit dyes a. Toxins in when our bodies are already working so hard eternally millennial-baiting Himalayan... I spent a little time looking into each of the amenities by a certified appraiser found them to. Acorn Spice and everythingfall which laundry detergent is better particularly attuned to hand soap brands, but few household. The ecosystem in this online course I teach you everything you need to you... Effective December 20, 2019 a subsidiary of AV Homes, which purchased. Attuned to hand soap brands, but theyre still relatively inexpensive all-purpose cleaners, laundry detergent available! Other tracking technologies and follow the Case are many baby care: there are many baby care: there over., too artificial, or too astringent he ordered the photos deleted customize your own mrs meyers lawsuit Mrs. Meyer #. He ordered the photos deleted, octoxynols, mrs meyers lawsuit nonoxynols on shipments to all States... Of Mrs. Meyers was everywhere can spritz around your room Meyers has to offer will send you personal vouchers you. Neighborhood bakery 26 different scents familys health using Method products for years and the millennial-baiting. Be worth roughly a quarter of that to know you better my own, I realized Mrs. Meyers offers soap. Too artificial, or cleaner, youll find CleanWell powered disinfecting technology these! When Mrs. Meyers has to offer sure is news to me why allow any more potential Toxins! Baby care products for me, no Mrs Meyerss products arent worth the potential harm my!
mrs meyers lawsuit